Vital Football

Latest Chelsea FC News

Four options to replace David Luiz

Four options to replace David Luiz

If we deem that is what is required.

Nonetheless, with Luiz now breaking into our midfield five, we could well do with the addition of a centre-back to the fray, with John Terry injured, that leaves just Ivanovic and Cahill as the fit centre-backs, whilst Cesar Azpilicueta is now our preferred right-back.

With Branislav Ivanovic able to play as a right back also, you would expect another defender to be a priority, even with 18 year old right-back Wallace soon to tie up a deal at Stamford Bridge and is expected to stay in Brazil until the end of the season.

Here are my favourite four centre-backs available at the moment, and a bit of a background about them:

Dedé - Vasco Da Gama - It is only a matter of time before the 6ft 4 Brazilian centre-back makes a move to one of Europe's elite, after breaking into the national team last year, he has snuck onto the radar, with AC Milan being linked, and even neighbours QPR were rumoured to be weighing up an audacious bid for the 24 year-old. The fruits of European football and the Premier League could well tempt the young star, and could be a great choice due to the fact we already have a host of Brazilians at the club, David Luiz, Oscar, Ramires, and of course Lucas Piazon, are sure to be around the Bridge for years to come. He could also be eased into the team, with Terry sure to be around for the next couple of years, I can imagine Dede would still be comfortable with a rotational role, and as we have seen this year, should we continue our European and domestic success, there would be plenty of chances for him to shine. He would be available for around £7-£8m, and as we have seen with Azpilicueta this year, cheaper certainly doesn't mean you have to cut-back on quality.

Ryan Shawcross - Stoke - A real John Terry-esque defender, Shawcross could be a perfect long term replacement for the our England man, and at just 25, he has already chalked up nearly 150 Premier League appearances, being the main talking point of a robust Stoke City defence, one that has only conceded 14 goals this season so far, which in fact is less than 12 of the last 20 Premier League winning teams at this stage, which says a lot. Shawcross has stated he isn't looking to leave Stoke, but has stalled on a new six-year deal at the club, and with just 18 months left on his contract, a bid of near £10m this January could definitely ruffle some feathers in their camp.

Mats Hummels - Borussia Dortmund - At 24, he is already a regular for both club and country, notching 137 Bundesliga appearances, and 23 caps for Germany since his rapid rise to fame since 09/10.Likened to the great Franz Beckenbauer, I would class him as a more sensible David Luiz, able to showcase his attacking mind, whilst also being an absolute rock in defence, as well as harnessing the pace and strength to make him an all-round pain in the posterior to opposition strikers. Hummels has recently signed a new contract with the German side until 2017, although a large bid could tempt him to England, as he has already picked up both the Bundesliga title twice, and the German equivalent of the FA Cup, he may well want to pursue new challenges and titles. Dortmund have the edge of being in the Champions League still, making a January move less likely, although with us already scooping the trophy, and realistically having more of a chance to win it again, he may well decide it is best for his career. A bid of around £20-£25m though may be needed, although that is hardly a figure that would scare away our owners.

Jeffery Bruma: currently on loan from Chelsea to Harmbug SV

Of course, all of this is hypothetical, although with the vast riches available to Abramovich, it really wouldn't surprise me if we did try and replace David Luiz now it looks like he`s settled in midfield. If so, I don't think he could do far wrong with any of these four choices.

Click here to join in the debate on the club forum.

Date:Saturday December 29 2012
Time: 10:31AM


tomas kalaas....i think he is the one who can replace john terry after his retirement and can be our future capatain...
29/12/2012 10:47:00
Also we could recall Chalobah for the 2nd half of the season or bring back Michael Essien
29/12/2012 11:04:00
We got plenty of fine options so replacin luiz is not a problem..we have ake and chalobah (a bit like luiz dm & cb) ,kalas who's like brana(rb and cb) who need a new replacement though shawcross would be just perfect
29/12/2012 11:35:00
would love hummels been a fan for years. would love to poach a few of the dortmund squad
29/12/2012 12:16:00
1) Shawcross (25, 6ft 3): Will be my first choice although I do think ManU must have put a clause/agreed with Stoke that you will not sell him to top 4 opposition. I think If we try to buy him ManU will get the first priority. 2) Kalas/Chalobah: IMO they are light weight to play in CB position. They will get brushed aside easily. 3) Anderson Vital da Silva (Dede, 24, 6ft 4)/Mats Hummels (24, 6ft 3): I have never seen them play so can't comment on them. I am not sure will they suit EPL.
29/12/2012 12:36:00
This is totally premature. Luis has played 3 games in midfield, all against mediocre oppostion. In my mind this has just increased his versatility for the side but to be talking of a permanent move for him to the midfield ..whoa hold on there. In every game Luis has played in the middle he has looked good going forward but virtually every time he has lost the ball or broken formation we have been in trouble. Before people start talking of him being the second coming of Makelele (as a DM) which i dont think he is, or our version of Andrea Pirlo (as a CM) which i suspect may be his better position, let us see how he looks in the middle when we play decent everton. If we need another CB btw my choice is to recall Bruma. This annoying practice of chelsea FC buying players for fun while having the equivalent of two teams in players on loan and unused is unsustainable and needs to stop.
29/12/2012 14:00:00
'll recall bruma tooo....folks on here may think otherwise..but i think the guy has really grown...
29/12/2012 14:17:00
Mats Hummels (he is German they good in any league.. FACT... Kalas's reading of the game will help him a great deal..
29/12/2012 14:22:00
Nicely written article mate, but I think we need to thread carefully before we make any rashg decision
29/12/2012 14:28:00
either way we need cover in CB / CDM position(s) in Jan + striker
29/12/2012 15:16:00
Shawcross will be my 1st choice given his Bpl experience. I see him settling in just like Cahill and he wont cost much. If we are sure of Bruma,it will make lotta sense if we get bring him back.
29/12/2012 15:20:00
GabeU, i dont see why it should considered premature to move Luiz to D.midfield more and more going by the fact he has succeeded there even before he was deployed that position. If you watch his game closely you will know he is tailor made for the mid. And the issue of him going to CM shouldnt even arise cos him being moved to the DM is a case of necessity rather than luxury,put differently,we needed an urgent cover there unlike in the CM where we have abundant options. We must understand that he makes our mid more intimidating and it reflects in the result of the matches he played there for us irrespective of how low you would categorize the opponents. We thrashed teams that can ordinary pose huge threat for us and they automatically becomes a case of a mediocre opponent. Now it is no longer a call to move him to DM,it is now move him to CM. From CM some people will start saying he is best for the CF.
29/12/2012 15:47:00
We need a proper DM. Not a CB to replace Luiz.
29/12/2012 18:18:00
Good defenders but weve got our very own players in Bruma,Chalobah,Kalas,Nathan Ake! Why should we buy another? We have also got Wallace to compete for the right back position,Chalobah and Bruma are very versatile as well. We cant just buy and buy and buy,why do you people think we have an academy? Just for the fun of it?????
29/12/2012 20:15:00
Bruma cant get into the Hamburg side right now there is talk of sending him to Vitesse, Right now Kalas is a far better prospect than Bruma, its a shame I really used to like Bruma but his future witg us is not looking promising.
29/12/2012 21:38:00
Jores Okore on ma mind...shawcross would also be perfect
29/12/2012 21:42:00
It's not premature to adress the issue; even though Luiz only pulled off 3 games as a midfielder, he was too much a defensive liability (sure, Terry, Brana and Cahill also move up for corners, but never loose the ball dribbling or try to make difficult passes that are intercepted). And because of that, Luiz is more akin to Ramires/Romeu than Mikel/Chalobah. Let's not plan for Luiz to return to any defensive duties, but unleash him as a box-to-box player. But with Nathan Ake, (whom I rate significantly higher than Bruma), there's no need to buy a new CB as Terry'll be back in a week or so.
30/12/2012 04:57:00
There is no need to replace him. He should be played as holding midfielder where he has excelled. Temporarily he can be a backup centre back. We save a lot of money by doing so. A new holding midfielder isn't in integrated into our system of play. I'd ask you firstly who is playing better in this position from our current players? Not Mikel, not Lampard, not Romeu.
30/12/2012 08:21:00
It doesnt sound good though that in that defense there is no single player from Cfc system to understudy the more experienced players. It would be nice to have any of Kalas,Hutch,Bruma etc in the mix to have a look in once in a while.
30/12/2012 09:19:00
For the moment Kalas propably is the first central defender to have a chance at Chelsea. I hope he continues his good work and can impress enough for his chance.
30/12/2012 09:31:00
Page 1/2
  1. 1
  2. 2

Login to post a comment

Recent Chelsea Articles

Your MOTM v Barcelona (a) Was?

Okay, Chelsea may have lost 3-0 against Barcelona, at the Nou Camp on Wednesday evening, exiting the Champions League 4-1 on aggregate, but the team didn`t disgrace themselves.

Leicester v Chelsea (FA Cup) - Match Officials

The FA Cup takes centre stage this weekend before yet another international break sees the domestic season come to an abrupt halt for the rest of the month.

Name Your Starting XI - Leicester (a) FA Cup

All those hopes of the 2017 / 2018 season evolving into a season whereby Chelsea claim a plethora of silverware have diminished.

Who Should Conte Choose - Courtois or Caballero?

Following on from Chelsea`s disappointing exit from the Champions League, at the hands of Barcelona, it`s fair to say Thibaut Courtois copped for a lot of flak.

Chelsea Archived Articles

Vital Chelsea articles from

Site Journalists

Editor email
no email
Stan Wenners
no email
no email

Current Poll (see more polls)

Leicester (a) - FA Cup - Which Keeper Should Start?
Suggested By: merlin
ScoopDragon Premier League Network Sites
Write for Vital Football
Latest F1 News
Latest Vital Boxing News
The Vital Football Members League

Recent Chelsea Results (view all)

Chelsea Fixtures

Vital Members League Table

1.Michael Reid70
9.Eric Clarkson17
Vital Football Comment